I love a good camping gadget, I really do. But I've also been that person with a flat airbed because the car battery died, watching smugly organised campers who brought a simple foot pump. This highlights the great dilemma for modern campers: do you opt for battery powered convenience or foolproof manual reliability?
An Honest Disclosure
This site is 100% reader supported. Some links in this guide might be affiliate links (e.g., to Amazon). If you buy something through them, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. I never accept free products or payment for positive reviews. You can read my full affiliate disclosure here.
The Powered Choice
Offers incredible speed, convenience, and comfort, but requires a power source and adds a layer of complexity. Great for family trips where ease is a priority.
The Manual Alternative
Guarantees foolproof reliability and works anywhere, anytime. It's often lighter and cheaper, but requires more time and physical effort.
To help you decide what's right for your kit, I'm putting some classic camping gear dilemmas head to head.
The Air Pump Dilemma: Electric vs. Manual
The Electric Air Pump
- Incredibly fast and effortless
- Essential for large, double height airbeds
- Requires a power source (car or EHU)
- Can be quite noisy for campsite neighbours
The Manual Foot Pump
- Works anywhere, anytime. Utterly reliable.
- Very quiet and lightweight
- Takes a lot of time and physical effort
- Can be awkward to get the last bit of pressure in
Adam's Recommended Gear
Rechargeable Electric Pump
"A rechargeable pump is the best of both worlds. You get the speed and power without needing to be tethered to your car. Inflating a huge family airbed in 90 seconds is a luxury you won't want to give up."
Check Price on AmazonAdam's Verdict:
"For a big family airbed, I'll always use an electric pump. But I *never* go camping without a simple manual pump tucked away in the boot. It's the ultimate foolproof backup plan. My advice? Own both."
The Cooling Conundrum: Electric vs. Standard
This is one of the biggest upgrades you can make. While a standard cool box is a staple, an electric one genuinely changes how you camp and what you eat.
The 12V Electric Cool Box
- Acts like a true portable fridge, keeping food properly cold
- No soggy food from melted ice packs
- Requires constant power (EHU or power station)
- Expensive and heavy compared to standard boxes
The Standard Cool Box
- Simple, cheap, and very portable
- Doubles as a handy seat or table
- Only as good as your ice packs, which melt over time
- Risk of soggy food at the bottom
Adam's Recommended Gear
Electric Camping Cool Box
"An electric cool box is a true upgrade for family camping. It's a proper portable fridge, meaning no more soggy sandwiches from melted ice, and you can safely store milk, meat, and cheese for days."
Check Price on AmazonAdam's Verdict:
"For any trip longer than a single night, an electric cool box is a fantastic investment. The ability to have fresh milk for your tea on day three is a luxury you won't want to give up."
The Lighting Debate: Rechargeable vs. Gas
The USB Rechargeable Lantern
- Completely safe to use inside a tent
- Easy to recharge via USB from a power bank
- The battery has a finite life
- Doesn't provide any warmth
The Gas Lantern
- Bright, warm, and very atmospheric light
- Runs for a very long time on one gas canister
- Cannot be used inside a tent due to fire and CO risk
- The glass and mantles are fragile
Adam's Recommended Gear
Rechargeable LED Lantern
"Modern LED lanterns are brilliant. They're bright, safe to use inside a tent, and many can even be used as a power bank to charge your phone. A quality one is an essential, versatile piece of kit."
Check Price on AmazonAdam's Verdict:
"Safety first: for inside the tent, it has to be a rechargeable LED. However, for sitting outside, you can't beat the warm, hissing glow of a gas lantern. It just *feels* like proper camping. I use both on every trip."
The Power Play: Power Station vs. Solar Panel
The Portable Power Station
- Provides a large amount of reliable, silent power
- Works in any weather, day or night
- Heavy and can be expensive
- Has a finite charge until you can get to a plug
The Portable Solar Panel
- Generates free, sustainable power from the sun
- Lightweight and highly portable
- Only works in direct sunlight (not just daylight)
- Less useful in overcast UK weather
Adam's Recommended Gear
Portable Power Station
"A good power station is the ultimate off-grid upgrade. It's a silent, safe power source that can run a cool box, charge all your devices, and power your lights for a whole weekend.
Check Price on AmazonAdam's Verdict:
"This is a trick question – they're not competitors, they're a team! For a weekend trip, a pre-charged power station is all you need. For a week-long off-grid adventure, using a solar panel to top up your power station is the ultimate setup."
Frequently Asked Questions
Is powered camping gear worth the extra cost?
For family camping where comfort and convenience are priorities, powered gear like an electric cool box or air pump is often worth the investment. For minimalist or budget camping, reliable manual gear is always the smarter choice. The best approach is often a mix of both: powered items for big comforts, and manual backups for essential safety gear.
What's the best way to power gear if I don't have an Electric Hook-Up (EHU)?
If you're camping off-grid, a portable power station is the best solution. These are large rechargeable batteries with multiple outlets (USB, 12V, and even a 3-pin plug). You charge it at home before you go, and it can power your lights, charge phones, and even run a low-wattage cool box for a weekend.
What's the one piece of manual gear I should never replace?
For me, it has to be a reliable fire starting method. While a USB arc lighter is a cool gadget, it can run out of battery. A simple, waterproof tub of matches or a flint and steel should have a permanent home in your emergency kit. It's the one thing you know will work when everything else fails.
